Ministry for the Future

Title: Review - "The Ministry of the Future"

Kim Stanley Robinson's, "The Ministry of the Future", is undeniably an ambitious novel. Esteemed for his brilliantly envisioned science fiction, Robinson seeks to offer a fresh lens to view climate change - and perhaps therein lies the book's greatest strength and its most glaring weakness.

The book takes us on a riveting journey that begins in 2025 with the establishment of an organization, ironically named the Ministry for the Future. Its mandate is simple yet profound; advocate for future beings and protect all life forms, present and forthcoming. A story recounting the trials of this new ministry, fraught with complications and challenges, unfurls into an engaging narrative that holds your attention from the start.

Robinson’s story shines in the careful crafting of climate change’s apparent reality. It's not a far-off apocalypse but a brewing storm just over the horizon that we might still have the chance to overcome. The story, experienced through fictional eye-witness accounts, adds an immersive depth, painting a desperate yet hopeful picture of our planet's climate-challenged potential future.

However, the strength of this narrative is somewhat dulled as the book progresses. Each problem this ‘Ministry’ faces is introduced, meticulously examined, and subsequently solved. This template reiteration raises stakes that are too swiftly quelled, leaving the latter part of the book struggling to fill the void. The urgency of a planet on the edge is lost, along with the pressing need for the reader to cling on to the narrative.

As the book meanders into its final quarter, searching for new problems to solve, the narrative unfortunately starts to feel stretched thin. The exhilarating tension and urgency that once drove the story gradually get diluted, turning pages feels more hard work than inspired curiosity.

In conclusion, "The Ministry of the Future" is testament to Robinson's unparalleled imagination. The novel is immediate, impactful, and original yet struggles with its pacing, particularly towards the end. Despite its occasional narrative stumbles, it undeniably stands as one of the most powerful and distinctive books on climate change.

The Ministry for the Future follows the history of the eponymous ministry created by the UN in 2025 to represent the interests of future people when addressing #ClimateChange; given that the solutions to climate change will take effect over hundreds of years, so don't immediately benefit the current generations, the ministry would speak for future generations in order to ensure long-term thinking is applied.

The novel has three main characters: Frank, who we meet in the first traumatising chapter, is an American relief worker, and the only survivor of an Indian town struck by a devastating heatwave that wipes out millions. Frank suffers the rest of his ruined life with acute PTSD, which drives him ever more desperately find ways to avoid such a catastrophe from repeating. Early in the novel, it spurs him to actions that introducing us to the second main character:

Mary, an Irish lifetime diplomat, is the Minister for the Future, a role that make her a target for activists from both sides of the climate struggle, and requires her to assemble and coordinate a team to establish legal standing for future generations, and promote solutions that protect them.

The novel interleaves short chapters between Frank and Mary and the third main character: The Situation Itself. This unusual character's chapters are either extremely short whom-am-I riddles that impart a set of disparate but germane concepts, or they are vignettes told from the perspective of unnamed witnesses to some aspect of climate change's effects or solutions.

Appreciating that the story is global, vast, and epic helps to understand that this apparently scattershot narration style is a cleverly devised mechanism (and maybe the only way) to ensure that the novel includes everything needed to grasp the problem and its solutions. Indeed, in parts it's so saturated that it reads like a draft of a #CliFi novel, with long lists and shorthand notes, that was rushed to print before some of the chapters were fleshed out, and maybe before some of the events played out in reality!

The novel is somehow both harrowingly realistic and implausibly optimistic, in that some of the manifold solutions involve changes that just seem impossible to achieve. But Robinson already understands my pessimism and dread:

"... the order of your time feels unjust and unsustainable and yet massively entrenched, but also falling apart before your eyes. The obvious contradictions in this list might yet still describe the feeling of your time quite accurately…"

On reflection, although it may be naive, it's also possible the exact formula we need in order to confront inexorable, nonfictional climate change that is definitely already arriving.

So his answers for both, basically: maximalism. The point he's sort of making is that making the planet safely inhabitable is going to take every tactic and every ideology not necessarily working together but working on some piece of the thing. No one actor gets to be the hero (though I do enjoy that KSR's favorite kind of protagonist remains the middle-aged competent lady technocrat–guy's got a type) and while he's sort of indicating that capitalism as we know it has to die, he's not saying that happens through inevitable worker uprising. Some of it's coercion of central banks and some of it's straight-up guerrilla terrorism. Geoengineering happens at varying scales for better and for worse. Massive economic collapses occur. Millions die. And the point I think from KSR is that's the outcome in his most optimistic take. In general with KSR I don't know if I ever fully agree, but I always feel fully engaged.

This is also probably the most not-novel-y of his novels in that there's a couple of recurring characters running through the book but a ton of it's just first-person unnamed narration of events happening around the world. Someone describing a drought, a refugee describing a camp, a miner describing the nationalization of his mine. One very weird and fun chapter from the point of view of actual carbon.